Witnessing the Witnesses
A first for me after 12 years of documenting work: I was asked for a contribution on what was said (and NOT said) at a symposium of 14 research projects from Africa, Asia, and Latin America.
Extraction is a shared pattern
Across the regions represented by both the Feminist Internet Research Network (FIRN) and Resistance and Resilience (R&R) research projects, the same pattern appeared in their shared challenges: A pervasive tech-supported extraction of everything we cherish about our lives and planet. Where direct extraction isn't useful, we find repression too; outspoken women and defenders are silenced through attacks online and offline in Tajikistan, Brazil, and beyond.
Latin America: Industrial corridors, illegal logging and gas pipelines extract ancestral forest territories from the Zapotec, Purépecha, and Yaqui communities of Mexico. In Brazil, we see the material extraction of minerals for phones and data centres that extract land and water, alongside mainstream digital platforms extracting the dignity, labour and personal data of Black women. Communities get "sugar internet" that dissolves in the rain. In Uruguay, encounters with sex workers led to the reflection that even participatory research can extract stories and labour.
Africa: In Egypt, tech companies and the state collude to extract profit, data and obedience from migrants, queer people and activists. Ethiopia's queer community faces extraction of identity through doxxing, catfishing and coordinated information disorders that force people into exile. South Africa's Black women have their bodies and images extracted for colonial fetishisation in dating apps, while university students have their attention and mental health extracted by platforms with no accountability. In Kenya, rubies, oil and gold are extracted from the Ogiek, Endorois, and Sengwer lands, driving forest evictions and state-allied violence. The research itself tried to break the extraction pattern by training community enumerators instead of bringing in outside experts.
Asia: Mining projects in the Philippines expel Indigenous people to extract minerals from their lands. In India, trans sex workers are doxxed, mental health records are abused to expel students and personal information is extracted to entrap, blackmail or exile queer and Dalit activists. In Lebanon and Palestine, settler colonialism is a continuous extraction of land, life, and spectacle. Technology accelerates this by separating the witness from the martyr.
These transgressions are met everywhere with institutional failure: police who blame the victim, courts with no laws for "click crimes" and platforms that openly host coordinated harassment. The academy is not an institution separate from this failure. It too extracts knowledge, disciplines language, and decides who gets to speak. It is therefore of little surprise that refusal was a theme in the symposium, that researchers spoke of stepping away, refusing to engage with Global North frameworks, and making their own spaces outside of "business as usual" research and systems that were never designed to protect what we care about most.
Visibility as a site of struggle
In this shared landscape of extraction and institutional failure, our communities and defenders are staying safe by navigating visibility as a site of struggle. Instead of demanding more visibility, they are carefully choosing when to be seen, when to speak and when to step away.
Queerness: Queer people in multiple regions have learned that being seen is dangerous. In Egypt and India, queer individuals use pseudonyms or stay closeted online because "being closeted is much safer." In Ethiopia, queer people shift away from public platforms entirely, finding safety in anonymous accounts, hotel rooms and the privacy of apartments. In South Africa, LGBTQ+ students are "laughed at" when they report online violence, so they do not report at all, stepping away from platforms altogether to heal and continue surviving.
Land defenders: In the Philippines, environmental defenders face red-tagging, where they are labelled communist insurgents or terrorists. Military surveillance follows. Being visible online means becoming a target, said Marie: "Visibility must be strategically governed, not maximised. It is not a neutral good." In Brazil, Indigenous and Quilombo communities face the violent entry of technology like Starlink, data centres and mining. Big Tech is often accompanied by organised crime and state forces. Visibility on social media can call in more attacks or surveillance. In Kenya, defenders who report online violence to police are asked for bribes; others do not report at all because "all kinds of violences are supposed to be dealt with within the community."
Algorithmic overwhelm: Across all regions, the same Meta platforms (Facebook, WhatsApp, Instagram) were demonstrably unsafe and extractive information spaces. South African university students "ignore, block, move on," sometimes deleting social media entirely "because the toxicity was too much." Ethiopian queer people shift away from platforms to protect their mental health. Brazilian Black women practice "digital care" by making strategic decisions about when to engage, informed by the knowledge that these platforms were not designed for their wellbeing. Also in Brazil, MariaLab offered another path instead of stepping away entirely, when a helpline learned forensic triage to give survivors certainty about whether they were being surveilled.
Unbearable language: In Lebanon and Palestine, Ghiwa spoke of how the coloniser's language can become so unbearable, colleagues refused to write at all. The research collective had to reorganise as a hive of different roles and shared labour to cope with how the act of writing in the language of the coloniser was itself a violence amidst ongoing genocide: "We have to be limited, so that we are not playing into that same language and those same tools of killing."
The attention that amplification brings is not guaranteed safety in our present shared landscapes of tech-enabled surveillance. In a world of pervasive spectacle and increasingly well-understood technology-facilitated gender-based violence (TFGBV), disengaging is a valid response to widespread institutional failure.
Using research to make solidarity
Once we refuse and step away, where should we go? My humble intervention to this symposium is that we head towards each other.
Across all our regions, the attacks we face are not random. Coordinated harassment campaigns, red-tagging, doxxing, state-sponsored hate — these are organised and coherent efforts.
We can consider that they are also an expression of solidarity. "There are ways of being in solidarity that ultimately undermine the very possibility of solidarity," wrote Nathan Rochelle DuFord in 2022.[1] This happens because the goals of the group "are designed to undermine the broader foundations of society." DuFord described antisocial solidarity — one "that aims to make material the psychic conditions necessary for domination" — to distinguish it from prosocial solidarity. He continued:
When solidarity is practiced in such a way as to forefront individual achievement, domination or success, the solidarity produced becomes antisocial and in some ways self-contradictory [...]
This is because the solidarity needed to achieve the goals of the group would undermine overall group cohesion when achieved. In short, there are pitfalls to moralising solidarity, because it can function for domination too.
What can change if we register this evidenced pattern of extraction and aggression against our communities and planet — the coordinated attacks on queer Ethiopians, the red-tagging of defenders in the Philippines, the harassment campaigns against women everywhere, the platform mobs in India and South Africa — as organised, effective and relentless forms of antisocial solidarity?
The research presented at this symposium offers the potential of prosocial solidarity to us in the Global South, a bouquet of over a dozen chances for us to extend our allyship and spread the work of a solidarity that seeks to reduce domination and exclusion in all our spaces, and to build communities instead of neglecting them. For example, now that Black researchers have offered us thorough articulations on anti-Blackness, how can non-Black researchers and defenders use that available knowledge to extend their acts of prosocial solidarity against anti-Blackness and misogynoir instead of leaving that effort to the most affected? We saw through Sangath's work in India that a gender lens is insufficient when caste, class, disability and ethnicity all interlock.[2] If identitarian relationships are insufficient for prosocial solidarity, how can we respond by moving together in other types of relationships?
And beyond the represented territories[3] of the room we were in, what can we do in solidarity with defenders who will never be granted feminist and decolonial research? If the same patterns of extraction and repression are already widespread in our regions, to what extent will we need research from even more parts of the planet to form prosocial solidarity against coordinated antisocial forces?
The symposium gathered Global South researchers to better understand inequalities and power relations across movements.[4] To move with recognition of our shared patterns and enemies (even if not specifically named in the room) is one way to refuse the coloniality of Global North institutions. Generating Global South solidarity out of Global South research could send the message: We see each other even when we are trying not to be seen. We are able to learn from each other in the face of united aggression. And maybe we do not need to demand more knowledge be produced for us to act together on what we already know is true.
If we do not use our shared knowledge to make and coordinate strategic prosocial solidarity with each other against the organised antisocial solidarity we already face, we risk surrendering solidarity itself to the realm of those who wield it for domination, exclusion and extraction. There is likely nothing that we will want to recover from institutions of militarism and the prison cage once they fail us completely. However, the same cannot be said of the academic institution, argued Soniya Munshi and Craig Willse in 2017, where there are elements worth saving still:
Our task then is to think about how to nurture these elements to prepare them for their lives outside their current institutional forms.[5]
How do we start? I think of Ghiwa from Kohl here, who said we should understand the politics of disruption by first seeing ourselves as being a "glitch" in the institution, a necessary interruption to the "endless" settler-colonial mindset that we reject.[6]
On the first day of the symposium, Srinidhi recalled how illuminating it was for disabled researchers in Bangladesh, India and Pakistan to be able to examine a large TFGBV dataset through the lens of disability — something not possible for them before.[7]
In what ways can we do the same now with prosocial solidarity: to look at the knowledge made and shared across regions here, and wield it in a refusal to abandon[8] each other in overlapping crises? The solidarity potential that the research symposium made possible across our regions was the invitation for us to practice finding these answers together.
With gratitude to Tigist Shewarega Hussen and Lori Nordstrom. Liy Yusof (they/them) is a disabled knowledge worker in and from the margins of Southeast Asia. They were tasked with documenting the Making Meaning research symposium (2026) and writing its postscript. Liy has for over 10 years worked with transnational, regional and local community builders, organisations, and feminist funds to align their documentation and learning with internal practices.
DuFord, N. R. (2022). Solidarity in Conflict: A Democratic Theory. Stanford University Press. ↩︎
Sharin Dsouza and Joshua Mark George presented on behalf of Sangath, an Indian mental health and research organisation working on health equity for queer and disability communities. Their FIRN research project, The TransNET project, examined the intersectional experiences of TFGBV among transgender, non-binary, and gender-diverse persons in India. Their symposium presentation highlighted how navigating multiple marginalised identities — such as caste, religion, ethnicity and disability — complicates TFGBV, proving that gender alone is insufficient to map the harm experienced by queer and trans individuals. ↩︎
Territories represented in the room of April 2026: Brazil, Egypt, Ethiopia, India, Kenya, Lebanon and Palestine, Mexico, the Philippines, South Africa, Tajikistan and Uruguay. Solidarity with Sudan was also mentioned at the beginning of every day. ↩︎
See: https://firn.genderit.org/research/event-report-making-meaning-feminist-conversations-research-resistance-hope-and ↩︎
INCITE! Women of Color Against Violence. (2017). Foreword. In INCITE! Women of Color Against Violence (Ed.), The Revolution Will Not Be Funded: Beyond the Non-Profit Industrial Complex. Duke University Press. ↩︎
Ghiwa Sayegh presented on behalf of Kohl, an independent publisher and journal focused on body, gender and queer research from the SWANA region. Their FIRN research project, We are the interruption: Technology, militancy and endless genocide, explores genocide as a continuum of settler colonialism and what a truly decolonial act of resistance looks like. Their symposium presentation addressed the unbearable violence of colonial language and digital infrastructure, arguing that resistance means embracing limitation and becoming the "glitch" that interrupts endless expansion. Such an approach also asks of us to embrace our limitations instead of perpetuating pursuits of endlessness. ↩︎
See the Accessibility, Language, and Tech for the People (ALT) research-in-action process here https://whoseknowledge.org/building-accessible-multilingual-tech/ and briefing note https://whoseknowledge.org/initiatives/language-justice/alt-briefing-note/. Also highlighted in The Wire in May 2025: https://thewire.in/rights/accessible-futures-unequal-present-how-tech-gap-affects-visually-impaired-people-in-south-asia ↩︎
Hayes, K. (2023). 'Relationships, Reciprocity, and Struggle.' In K. Hayes and M. Kaba, Let This Radicalize You: Organizing And The Revolution Of Reciprocal Care. Haymarket Books. ↩︎
Relatedly:

